Ruth Donnelly speaks to leading aesthetic practitioners regarding their recommendations for treating pigmentation problems using skincare
The treatment of pigmentation is a rapidly emerging market in aesthetics. “Dark patches, irregular skin tone, sun spots on the hands, face, chest, neck and red faces are some of the most ageing conditions on the skin,” says esteemed consultant dermatologist Dr Nick Lowe. Many practitioners treat the condition with laser and light-based treatments, using skincare as a complementary resource. However, with a recent influx of cosmeceutical products designed specifically for the purpose, some experts in the field assert that topical treatment should be every practitioner’s front line when it comes to pigmentation.
A 2012 study conducted by Dr Lowe showed that a combination cream programme can be as effective as treating pigmentation with Intense Pulsed Light. An independent double blind study was carried out on 24 randomly selected subjects with mild to moderate pigmentation, who received either the cream treatment (12 subjects) or IPL (12 subjects). Results showed that when measured with the complexion analysis computer, 10 of 12 subjects (83%) of those treated using the cream treatment programme showed improvement, as did those treated with IPL (10 of 12 subjects/83%).1 “This study clearly shows that a daily combination of the right creams can be highly effective for redness and pigmentation,” says Dr Lowe.
With the number of ways to treat pigmentation evidently on the rise, approaches vary. However, most leading practitioners agree that skin preparation is key. “People with colouration need to be medically blended as best they can before they go on to further treatment,” says Beverly-Hills based dermatologist Dr Harold Lancer. “So the protocol in my clinic is that everyone is evaluated by me then at the end of that consultation a treatment plan is created to include lightening, exfoliating and epidermal and dermal rebuilding agents; topical medical treatments are used for at least a two to four week period before any instrumentation is considered.”
Dr Mervyn Patterson agrees that skin needs to be fully prepped before the commencement of any treatment, be it laser, IPL or topical. “It’s important to control all aspects of the pigmentation process whilst at the same time controlling inflammation, without disrupting the external skin barrier,” he says. “Tackling pigmentation without first repairing the skin barrier and dampening chronic inflammation would be like repainting the walls of a building without first fixing the roof.”
Although commonly thought of as an age- or ethnicity-related issue, people of all ethnic groups, ages and both genders experience pigmentation problems. However, the way you treat the problem will differ depending on many factors, foremost of which, according to Dr Lancer, is the patient’s ancestry. “Pigmentation concerns are the most difficult arena in cosmetic dermatology,” he says. “Because the lighter the ancestry – not just the clinical presentation of the patient, but the geographical origin of their great- grandparents and grandparents – the chances are, the better result from treatment. So if you have a pigmentary problem in a person from a Swedish origin then chances are you will get a better result than in someone with a fairer complexion but who is from a Moroccan or Italian ancestry.” Founder of Pharmaclinix Advanced Cosmeceuticals and chemist, Shashi Gossain agrees that pigmentation is a complex issue. “Types of skins and types of melasma are very different,” she says. “Some people have very light patches, and some patches are very deep due to long exposure to sun damage, so you have to be careful and specific on what and how you treat. You absolutely cannot use lasers to treat hyperpigmentation on skin types III to V, because of the risk of post- inflammatory hyperpigmentation, which is a lot more common in the darker skin tones.”
Hydroquinone has been deemed to be the gold standard for the treatment of pigmentation for over 50 years2. However, it has been reported that 80% of patients can develop a resistance to hydroquinone if used for more than a few months3, and the ingredient has also been shown to cause ochronosis, a skin condition presenting as severe, irreversible darkening and coarsening of the skin, in darker Fitzpatrick skin types.4 Although hydroquinone can still be found in most of the major prescription-only skincare lines, some doctors prefer not
to use the ingredient, for reasons of both safety and efficacy. “I reject hydroquinone or hydroquinone/retinoid combinations because of the irritation rates and risk of profound rebound of pigmentation once the bleaching agents are withdrawn,” Dr Mervyn Patterson explains. Dr Lowe takes a different approach, combining agents to achieve optimal results. “It’s key when treating pigmentation to use a combination of numerous safe lightening agents to work on different aspects of melanin production. This is a preferable approach to only using prescription hydroquinone products.” Other practitioners claim that the ingredient can be used safely if clinicians are cautious: Dr Lancer says, “We use hydroquinone treatment under tremendous clinical observation; we don’t use prescription level hydroquinone, our chemists make it to our specification. Depending on how it’s manufactured and what it’s blended with, it works differently; discolouration from hydroquinone can occur only if it’s used in a misguided fashion.” The shift away from the use of hydroquinone has led cosmeceutical companies to conduct significant research into what other ingredients can be used to treat pigmentation problems. Lorna Bowes, aesthetic nurse and director of AestheticSource.com, UK distributor of NeoStrata, says, “There are multiple plant extracts known to resurface, reducing superficial hyperpigmentation, and inhibit tyrosinase, which is a key enzyme in the production of melanin.”
Although proven to effectively treat pigmentation, lasers and light sources do have their limitations. “There are many things that will not respond [to light-based treatment], even in the most ideal circumstance,” Dr Lancer explains. “There are certain hormonal situations such as oestrogen imbalance that can cause a high risk rate or non-response rate to lasers and light sources.”
Dr Marc Ronert, president and medical director of Image Skincare, claims that the new Iluma line from Image yields similar results to laser treatment. He adds that, “The active ingredients in the Iluma line have also been clinically proven to block melanin production, which is not possible with a laser.” These ingredients include Belides (bellis perennis (daisy flower)) and Indian Kudzu Pueraria tuberosa leaf cell extract, claimed by the company to limit melanogenesis.
Many clinicians clearly agree that it is possible to receive effective results
from the use of skincare products alone; however, patient education is key to yielding those results.
Dr Nick Lowe explains that the efficacy of a skincare range depends on the user’s commitment to the regime. “The biggest problem with treating pigmentation with skincare is patient compliance, especially regarding sun protection,” he says. “The secret of success is through compliance in the use of lightening products, and year-round sunscreen use is absolutely essential. The skin must always be protected with a day cream containing anti-oxidants and broad-spectrum UVB and UVA protection. Without this, any benefits from creams or IPL will be undone as sun exposure is one of the primary causes of pigmentation and contributes to redness. “Patient education about this is very important. There is a myth that patients need not apply their skin lightening creams if they are on a sunny holiday. This is absolute nonsense. In fact this is when they need it most.”
Lorna Bowes lists some of the key ingredients that she would recommend when choosing a skincare line to treat pigmentation
Dr Lowe’s most powerful skin lightening cream yet, the cream contains an increased number of skin lightening active ingredients, from three to nine. Octadecenedioic acid and liquorice root extract limit melanin production in the skin cells that produce pigment, niacinamide and azalaic derivative lightens skin, whilst ferulic acid provides natural antioxidant protection against pigmentation. Preliminary studies showed that 71% of subjects showed a visible reduction in the appearance of pigmentation spots, 77% of subjects reported a more even skin tone and 82% of subjects reported a more radiant complexion after just four weeks of use. “The key is to use products with proven active ingredients, such as niacinamide, liquorice extract and anti-oxidants,” says Dr Lowe.
“What really makes Iluma unique is the use of a revolutionary new delivery system called Vectorize Technology,” says Dr Ronert. The company claims that the Vectorize delivery system creates non-ionic vesicles that penetrate the deeper layers of the skin, releasing active ingredients for a prolonged time. With active ingredients including green tea extract, Dipeptide-16, Vitamin C and Coenzyme Q10, the Iluma range aims not only to correct pigmentation problems but to prevent their recurrence.
“An independent clinical study showed that Epionce MelanoLyte Pigment Brightening Lotion and Pigment Perfecting Serum are as effective as hydroquinone/retinoid combinations without the irritation5,” says Dr Patterson. “Epionce Pigment products contain a wide blend of proven botanical ingredients that are effective at controlling all the steps in the pigmentation process and at reducing inflammation.” Active ingredients include turmeric, paper mulberry, bamboo and apple, and the promotional pack claims that, if used together, the two products address all the steps leading to irregular pigmentation.
A brightening serum containing kojic acid, niacinamide, alpha-arbutin and linoleic acid, Medik8 White Balance Click claims to combat seven signs of hyperpigmentation, including sun damage, age spots, dark spots, melasma, uneven skin tone and blotchiness. “We use the Medik8 White Balance Click in our clinic because it contains a good concentration of a number of effective over-the-counter anti-pigmentation ingredients,” says Dr Williams.
NeoStrata Enlighten is a three-product regimen containing NeoGlucosamine, THC, Vitamin C, Oligopeptide 34 and selected plant extracts. “In a study presented at the European Academy of Dermatology meeting in 2012, NeoStrata Enlighten demonstrated efficacy when used alone to lighten hyperpigmented areas, as well as providing all over brightening of skin tone,” says Lorna Bowes. “A group of 30 ethnically diverse women used the Enlighten three product regimen for 16 weeks; clinical grading, chronometer measurement, photography and self-assessment were used to establish efficacy and 93% of patients showed clinical improvement within four weeks.”
With technology and products improving all the time experts agree that treatment for pigmentation can only get more effective in years to come. “The topical chemistry of products we use is reinvented every six to 18 months,” Dr Lancer says. “So chemistry and technology is always improving.” As consumers become ever more aware of the ageing effect of dark spots and uneven skin tone, clinics will need to have more tools at their disposal to treat a diverse range of patients, and it seems that skincare could play a pivotal role, as both a post-procedure regimen and a stand-alone treatment.
Disclaimer: Please refer to the European Commission directive 1223/2009 Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety for opinions on certain ingredients
Upgrade to become a Full Member to read all of this article.